We need you to settle a disagreement for us today.
One of us came across this picture in a shoe box recently. (Don’t judge, we never were good at scrap booking). This gem was taken of one of our children at the tender age of six weeks old. The mother of this baby looked like a zombie while the baby looked like…well…THIS….
Baby pictures of this infant at this age show variations of this totally cracked out expression. No joke. If the mother of the infant hadn’t been so deliriously tired from lack of REM sleep, she probably would have cried that her child looked like it was on a Jolt Cola bender in every.single.photograph.
Here’s where we need your help.
One of us thinks that, although the child thankfully grew out of the crazy face phase, the child is easily recognizable in that photo. The other of us thinks there aren’t any traces of the crazy faced baby in the child that baby has grown up to be.
As usual, we’re both entirely sure we’re right.
We are turning to y’all to settle this one.
Which child was once that crazy faced baby?
Choose wisely…we have a Starbucks riding on this one!
Let us know how you figured it out in the comments.
UPDATE: MYSTERY REVEALED: We are totally impressed with the way you sleuthed it out! Many of you were convinced the answers was all in the dimple. Others zeroed in on face shape and facial expressions.You guys are thorough and clearly love a challenge!!
It was Lisa who thought the answer would be obvious to all, and Ashley who thought it would be difficult. Clearly, it wasn’t a slam dunk even for most who got the correct answer. So…Ashley wins delicious Starbucks goodness, while Lisa lives to latte another day!
CLICK HERE for the identity of the crazy faced baby!!
I chose Lucy but only because of the dimple. I have to say, and I am ducking when I say this, I don’t really see any of them in that hilarious baby face. That picture is priceless and the only thing that would have made it even funnier is to see the tired mommy face along with it because that would pretty much sum up that stage of our lives, wouldn’t it?
Ooh, that’s a tough one! I just sent in who I thought it was, but I really had no idea. (The pink gave me a bit of a hint, but I could’ve easily gone the other way had the baby been wearing a different color). Interested to see who wins this bet!
I’m guessing Lucy because of that great dimple.
I went with four.
I went with #3…because of the dimple…maybe?
I went with number 3 based on the dimple more than anything. It’s not a 100%, definitely that one, but I think I feel a little unsure because I don’t know the kids personally and haven’t watched them grow up. But I would say there are traces of what we looked like as infants in us even as we age, so you can’t say that there’s absolutely no trace…But maybe just a small one.
Maybe if you had them all make the same face as the baby is making it would be easier? LOL 😉 
Boy, I don’t have a clue. I guessed Bobby but that’s just a wag, wouldn’t bet you anything on it.
I went with number two because well, I don’t have a reason, I just thought it was her!
LUCY!!! That picture is FREAKING HILARIOUS!! I want to see one of the tired mama to boot!
But I totally get that…I have NO pictures of me for like the entire first year…and if I find any I will burn them.
I guessed Lucy from the blue eyes, but not confident in the guess at all. Really a funny picture! Wild child!
I voted #3!
I chose Bobby, and now I’m thinking I’m wrong?!
The starbucks will be all cold and yucky when it came here anyway…hahahaa.
I wanted my husband’s opinion and showed him the baby picture to compare with the others and it threw him off a bit. I don’t think he was expecting it when I told him to ‘look at this baby photo!’
I guessed number two because of the nose! You can also see the dimple, too!
I went with #2! (Stopped in from SITS). I wasn’t really sure but I did like guessing. Can’t wait to find out if I’m right.
I went with #3. They’ve all got adorable dimples, but that smile just seems to tie them together for me.
Ooooh, we are LOVING the way you all are sleuthing this one out!! Some of you have made such a good points for it being a child that we know is wrong…you almost had us convinced!! Hahahaha!! Y’all are persuasive!!
It does seem like it’s not an open and shut case for the most part!
We will be posting the answer tomorrow!!
I voted Abby, but after looking at the comments about Lucy’s dimple, I think they may be right!
I knew it was a girl so number 1 is out lol I picked number 2 it looks more like her and she is almost making a funny face in that pic also.
I went with #2 because the expression looks kind of similar.
However, it was really hard to tell. I almost picked Bobby. Can’t wait to see who it is!!
Lucy…..it can’t be Bobby, unless Lisa was really that tired and dressed him in pink! And the cute dimple! Love the photos - before and after!
I picked number 4 - just because it was a gut instinct!
I was this close to picking Bobby, but then I noticed the pink. I guessed Emma, but I’m really bad at matching baby pics to older kids or adults. Fun game, and AMAZING baby picture. I love it so so so much!
I love this idea! So much fun! Can’t wait to find out…
I voted #2 for the cheekbones.
I went with number 2, there’s almost the same expression between the two photos! Thanks for stopping by my blog and commenting yesterday! Look forward to hearing a lot more from you!
First of all, all 4 of those children are just darling, but I voted for Lucy. The eyes gave it away (after the pink striped shirt and the dimple). Although I have to vote with whichever one of you doesn’t think the child looks exactly like the baby….this was tough!
Hmm. 4? I’m awful at guessing, ha.
I choose Lucy because of the deep dimple and the eyebrows.
I would know that face anywhere! I can probably find a few more to add to the collection
I helped name her and I would never forget her gorgeous face 
They all have that dimple. Dang it! I was seriously sitting here with two windows on overlap. Ahhh! I have a problem.
I’ll tell you who I picked after you tell me who it is. tee hee.
I thought Lucy because the nose seemed similar. But now that people mention the dimple.
I’m not going to be able to work until I know the answer. Thanks a lot. Eye roll.
My husband loves to study people’s faces and always comments on people’s noses. I think the shape of the nose and the dimple point to #3. Mama needs some Starbucks, hope I’m right!
I was teetering between Bobby and Lucy. I went with Bobby because of the dimple and shape of the chin.
I am guessing Lucy because of that dimple. And not to worry - I would NEVER judge you for having your photos in a box - 9 years of parenting and 3 kids and I have not one scrapbook in this house!
#3. Wild guess.
I picked Lucy! I believe she looks more like the baby then any of them
#3 Lucy. She’s wearing a pink, red, & white striped shirt so I figured girl based on that and she has an adorable dimple in both pictures.
I say Lucy because of the pink shirt and the dimple.
{Melinda} I was debating between Bobby and Emma… but I think Bobby and Caffiene Baby have the same lips!
I am going with #2..but it was a little difficult thankfully the pink hinted to look at the girls…fun fun fun
That was really fun
I bet if I did it with my boys, nobody could figure it out. They are like twins in their baby photos.
Aw! I just loved this post! I couldn’t figure it out at all, so Ashley definitely wins! So, so sweet, though.
All four children are beautiful.
Aw! That was fun! I picked Emma because of the red hair! So very cute and a fun interactive game. I want to play more now. Do you have anymore photos?
Oops, I clicked before I voted, and I was totally wrong! But I love all the pictures of your kids! They are cuties!
So cute. I missed it. I said number 4.
This is best post idea EVER! I love it!! That picture is so funny. I picked the wrong kid. That was hard!
There is no denying that is Lucy! At first I was going to say Bobby but, then I saw the pink shirt!